The Bay Island subdivisions are on the very northeastern tip of Siesta Key in Sarasota County. Bay Island is an actual island that is home to over 160 homes. There are three Bay Island subdivisions: Bay Island, Bay Island Shores, and Bay Island Park. About half of the homes sold on Bay Island are generally waterfront properties. Most have private pools.
The waterfront homes have breathtaking views of Sarasota Bay or Roberts Bay. Enjoy boating or fishing in these protected waters, or use Big Sarasota Pass to access the Gulf Of Mexico just a short ride west of the Island. The Nora Patterson Bay Island Park is on the eastern side of the island where you can enjoy water views, park benches, picnic tables, fishing, and walking paths. You also have easy access to the Sarasota mainland just a quarter mile past the park.
Try a new search, or click below to get notified when matching listings become available.